Pumpkin Pie Spice Cookies

Pumpkin Pie Spice Cookies can kick-start your autumn! We have a friend who is crazy about everything pumpkin spice. Some people say fall doesn’t begin until Pumpkin Spice lattes are available at Starbucks.

Initially I tried a pumpkin shortbread cookie recipe but found it to be too crumbly for what I wanted. The dough didn’t roll into nice smooth balls, and the edges split a lot when baked. Finally, I took my recipe for Espresso Cookies and adjusted it for pumpkin pie spice.

Why not use real pumpkin?

It takes a LOT of canned pumpkin to be able to get the pumpkin flavor. When you use that much in cookies, they turn out very soft and cake-like. I like a cookie that’s crispy on the outside and a little chewy on the inside. And, really, we all equate the actual spices with the flavor of pumpkin anyway.

Using parchment paper and portion scoops

I have been using parchment paper for years instead of greasing the cookie sheets. Parchment paper keeps things from sticking to the baking sheet and it doesn’t leave a greasy mess. If the baking sheets aren’t cleaned really well, the residue of cooking spray gets baked on. It takes a lot of work with a steel wool pad to get that off. I’d rather spend more time cooking and less time washing dishes.

I discovered portion scoops years ago, and they are essential kitchen tools. They come in a wide range of sizes, such as a large scoop that restaurants use to consistently measure out portions of muffin batter into baking cups or coleslaw into serving dishes. We use a small #70 scoop to top fruit with a scoop of sorbet.

Portion scoops are numbered. The larger the number, the smaller the scoop. The #40 scoop is my favorite size for cookies.

candy cornTop pumpkin pie spice cookies with candy corn and pumpkins

For a distinctly fall cookie, you can top pumpkin pie spice cookies with candy corn and candy pumpkins. Brach’s has both in their Autumn Mix. The candy will melt if you bake them with the cookies. As soon as the cookies come out of the oven, press the candy corn and pumpkins into the top of the soft, warm cookies.

Save the leftover pumpkin pie spice mix!

When you’ve rolled all the cookie dough balls in the pumpkin pie spice and sugar mixture, don’t throw it away. Using a sifter or fine mesh strainer, strain out all the little pieces of cookie dough. What’s left is a wonderful pumpkin pie spice sugar mix to add to your coffee.

Freeze pumpkin pie spice cookies

Best thing ever! For most cookies, you can freeze the dough balls and have them on hand to make fresh-baked cookies any time. It may take a few more minutes to bake the frozen dough balls. You can also freeze the baked cookies and keep them in an airtight container in the freezer. It’s a great way to have fresh cookies for unexpected visitors.

Stay at the Bottger Mansion for awesome cookies and much more!

The cottonwood trees along the Rio Grande River are turning gold. The nights are crisp and cold, and the days are sunning and still mild in November. Stay at the Bottger Mansion of Old Town Bed & Breakfast to enjoy numerous hikes, bike rides and strolls. Our historic home has modern amenities, including free WiFi throughout the property. All of our cookies are house-made–there’s nothing like fresh-baked cookies with afternoon coffee or tea. Old Town Albuquerque is right in the center of the city, so nothing is very far away. The Bottger Mansion is an oasis in the heart of Albuquerque! Check availability and plan your stay today!

Bottger Mansion front door

Scroll to Top
Great Holiday Shopping in Old Town Albuquerque
The Thanksgiving holiday is rapidly approaching, which, for many, marks...
The Best Things to do in Albuquerque This Winter
It may not seem like an obvious choice, but Albuquerque...
Waffles with Apple-Green Chile Compote
Waffles with apple-green chile compote are worth planning ahead. Make...

Adventure Starts Here!

Give The Gift of Bottger Mansion This Christmas

Give your loved one a very special gift of a stay at Bottger Mansion.  We offer gift certificates in many amounts.